Thursday, November 10, 2011

If you are persistent you will win

If you are persistent you will win

The health insurance claim of Sanjay (name changed) was rejected by the insurance company. Repeated attempts by the insured with insurance company at various levels were not successful. We as Insurance Brokerage Firm advised him to take up the matter with Insurance Ombudsman. The matter took some time as the office of Insurance Ombudsman is having large number of complaints or cases coming up every day. After processing the date were fixed, the case was taken up and finally the insurance company was ordered to pay the claim. We appreciate the persistence effort put in by the insured, which has brought success to him.

Outlook magazine of November 3, 2011 has carried the case of Dr Kunal Saha, a medical doctor working and residing in USA. His wife had died in Kolkatta in 1998 while undergoing treatment. Kunal was convinced that Dr. Sukumar Mukherjee, the top Kolkatta physician who first treated Anuradha, had inflicted on her a massive overdose of Depomedrol, a long acting corticosteroids that went on to play havoc with her immune system; and that the treatment that followed, involving other doctors and the Advanced Medicare Research Institute (AMRI) a reputed private hospital, had been appallingly negligent .Armed with both certainty and rage, Saha, himself, a Kolkatta trained doctor put his peers in the dock.

Saha had too traveled 50 times over 13 years to India to fight the legal battle. I admire this gentleman.

The claim of Saha was for Rs 77 crores but Supreme Court of India delivered a ruling in 2009 which vindicated his struggle. By finding the Kolkatta doctors negligent, it opened the door for compensation order to be passed.

In October 2011, National Consumer Redressal commission has ordered that three Kolkatta doctors who treated Anuradha and AMFI will have to pay Rs 1.73 crores. Net payment after deductions to Saha will be Rs 1.34 crores. According to Dr Kunal Saha the amount spent by him on legal battle has been of the order of Rs 5 crores.

The points coming up before us are;

1. We should be persistent in follow up of our case whether it is Health insurance claim against an Insurance Company or liability claim against someone, who has not performed his duty.

2. Were 3 doctors or AMFI having professional liability cover in 1998 from Insurance Company? If yes will the Insurance Company pay it?

Let us wait and watch.

1 comment:

RH said...

Hi, I came across your site and wasn’t able to get an email address to contact you. Would you please consider adding a link to my website on your page. Please email me back.

Thanks!

Harry
harry.roger10@gmail.com